One Too Many Witches: Murder Mystery Party Game

Available for download at checkout
Regular price $40.95
Product details
  • Type Download
  • SKU SPOILBREW
  • Age Range 13 to Adult
  • Minimum # of players 5 Suspects
  • Max Players (Main Game) 8 Suspects
  • Max players available 24 Suspects (Expansion Packs Sold Separately)
  • Difficulty rating Moderate, 4/10
  • Character roles All-Female
  • Game Duration 2 to 4 Hours Average (Flexible Timeline)
  • Game format Murder | Guided Clue Mingling | 4 Rounds
  • Vibe and Content Notes Clean Coven Drama * Wands, Whispers, Passive-Aggressive Potions
  • Date of publication 2006. Last Revised 2022.

A spooky and hilarious witch-themed murder mystery party game for 5–8 players, ages 13 and up, with all-female character roles.

This enchanting coven mystery is packed with powerful witches, magical rivalries, simmering grudges, strange spells, potion brewing, warlock gossip, and deadly trouble in Ravenwood Forest.

This is the instant download version, so there is nothing to ship and no shipping fee. Simply download, print, prepare, and play!

Prefer a professionally prepared game? Choose the Boxed Kit version, and our staff will professionally print and prepare the game materials for you.

Helpful Links:

Murder Mystery Party Game Synopsis:

The members of the 1300th Witch’s Coven are preparing to gather within the enchanted Ravenwood Forest for their annual assembly. The witches plan to brew powerful potions, practice new spells, and exchange the latest gossip about warlocks throughout the magical community.

Unfortunately, the chemistry within the coven has not been quite right lately. Several witches have openly complained about simmering feuds, wounded pride, and the growing lack of harmony among the group. A controversial proposal has surfaced requiring certain witches to attend counseling sessions before the annual gathering in hopes of repairing their fractured relationships.

Onyx Blazen, the powerful and fiery leader of the coven, has dismissed the objections and declared the sessions mandatory for everyone. Whether counseling can restore peace to this volatile group of magical personalities remains to be seen.

You are a member of the 1300th Coven and are expected to attend the gathering in Ravenwood Forest. This is where your story begins.

Host a Large-Group Murder Mystery Party Game:

  • Main Game: 8 unique suspect characters
    • Designed for 5–8 players.
    • Five characters are required, and three are optional.
    • All character roles are female.
  • Expansion Pack #1: 8 additional suspect characters
    • Sold separately.
    • Includes 8 female roles.
    • Expands the game to 16 unique suspects.
  • Expansion Pack #2: 8 additional suspect characters
    • Sold separately.
    • Includes 8 female roles.
    • Designed to be added after Expansion Pack #1.
    • Expands the game to 24 unique suspects.

Browse witchy décor, magical costume inspiration, potion-bar ideas, spooky party food, and more on the Pinterest board!

One Too Many Witches Will Spoil the Brew murder mystery party Pinterest board

Host Character List, Game Preview & Free Resources

This game is licensed for personal, private use only. If you plan to use it for any commercial purpose, public event, business, organization, school, fundraiser, church, promotional activity, paid event, or any use that generates revenue or provides a commercial benefit, you must purchase a Commercial License.

Purchase Commercial License

Video Trailer

Add a YouTube video URL in the theme editor to display a video here