Home
Help Choosing a Mystery

Help Choosing a Mystery

Welcome to the My Mystery Party Game Matching Matrix! Explore the options below to easily narrow down your selection of games.

LIST OF GAMES BY NUMBER OF REQUIRED PLAYERS - CLICK HERE

Subcategories:

Quick View

Tween Mystery Party Game | Echo Spy Academy

$49.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Trouble in Thornwood | Non-Murder Mystery

$51.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Mullets, Mayhem, & Murder

$51.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Bad Santa | A hilarious murder mystery party

$54.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Thanksgiving Murder Mystery Game

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

The Murder of Archibald Grim | Teen Mystery Party

$49.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Mystery Party Game | Mystery at the Oster Awards

$48.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Who Stole the Silver Bells Christmas mystery party

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Who Slayed Santa murder mystery party

$59.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Christmas toyshop mystery party

$52.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder Mystery Party | Bloodwood Masquerade Ball

$50.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Thanksgiving Mystery Party | Non-Murder

$48.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

'80s Murder Mystery Game

$50.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Ugly Christmas Sweater Murder Mystery Party

$53.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder at the Kringels Christmas mystery game

$50.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder Mystery Party | 1920s Grand Gatsby Theme

$47.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Christmas Reindeer Mystery Party

$48.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Homicide at the Tacky Sweater Shindig murder mystery

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Crazy Christmas Catastrophe mystery party

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Christmas Murder Mystery: T'was the Night Before Murder

$48.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

As the Ball Drops New Year's murder mystery

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

High School Reunion | 80's Prom Murder Mystery

$45.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder Mystery Party | Murder Behind the Mirror

$48.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder at the Poe's Raven Party

$50.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder Mystery Party | Saints & Sinners | My Mystery Party

$48.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Sin City Slayer casino murder mystery

$50.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Teen Idol Awards murder mystery

$50.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Vampire murder mystery party

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder Mystery Party | Devonshire Manor

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Chaos in the Cubicles | Corporate Mystery Party

$52.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder Mystery Party | Fairytale Themed | Once Upon a Murder

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Last Will of Hunter Bentley

$52.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

80s Murder Mystery Party Game | 1986

$50.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder on Baker Street

$51.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder Mystery Party | Circus Theme | Greatest Murder on Earth

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Zombie Escape | A mystery game

$46.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Last Will & Testament of Roland Kingsley

$53.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder Mystery Party | Escape Room Themed

$42.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Wild West Murder Mystery

$41.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Wine Tasting Murder Mystery Game

$40.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Panic at the House of Groove | 70's Mystery Party

$44.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder at Anonville Manor mystery party

$48.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Roman Toga Murder Mystery Party Game

$48.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Doom Mansion murder mystery game

$41.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder Mystery Party | Bloodstone Sanitarium Theme

$41.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

The Noxhelm Murders | A murder mystery game

$48.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder on the Buffalo Express | Mystery Party

$48.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

1990s Murder Mystery Party | Prognosis Murder

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Hatter's Ball | A Murder Mystery Game

$50.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Pirate Murder Mystery game

$41.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Witch murder mystery party

$40.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

1920s Murder Mystery Party on the Boardwalk

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder at the Stratford Castle murder mystery

$117.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Hero and Villain Summit murder mystery party

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder at the Album Release Party Game

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Abby Manor Masquerade Ball Murder Mystery

$52.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder at the Toadwart Inn murder mystery

$41.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder Mystery Party | Homicide at the Harrison House | Large Group

$117.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Back in Time for Murder Time Travel mystery party

$48.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Superhero Assassination Murder Mystery

$41.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

1950s Greaser Murder Mystery Party

$48.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Cadbury Mansion murder mystery game

$48.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Daunting Diamond Thievery mystery party

$41.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Factions | A Murder Mystery

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Scary Movie Night | a non-murder mystery party

$42.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder Mystery Party Game | Escape from Dregs Island

$48.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Game of Crowns

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder at the Plaza Ritz

$99.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

60s Murder Mystery Party Game

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

CSI murder mystery party game

$47.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

614 Scarlet Ct. Murder Mystery Block Party

$52.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder at the Magnolia Avenue Block Party

$46.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Poolside Murder Mystery Party

$50.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder Mystery Party | Backyard Luau Party

$47.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder in Maui - a Hawaiian Luau Murder Mystery

$41.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Grillin', Chillin', and Killin' murder mystery party

$46.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Haunted Hotel Murder Mystery Party | My Mystery Party

$41.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Valentine's Day Murder Mystery Game

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Find the Spy Before you Die mystery party

$42.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Turmoil at the Talent Show

$48.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Teen Mystery Party Game | Pajama Party Pandemonium

$46.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Teen CSI Mystery Party Game | Mystery at Godley Grove Manor

$44.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Find the Spy: Ms. Crimson

$42.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Pumpkin Palooza Costume Ball Mystery

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Wacky Pumpkin Town Panic | Family Halloween Whodunit

$46.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Monster murder mystery party

$52.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder at Skull Manor Costume Ball murder mystery

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Holly O. Wene's Halloween Party mystery game

$40.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Haunted house murder mystery game

$48.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Halloween Homicide in Dark Cloud murder mystery

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Zombie Murder Mystery Game

$48.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder at the Walgrave Astoria Costume Ball

$52.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Bridal Shower Murder Mystery | My Mystery Party

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Murder at the Mardi Gras Masquerade Ball game

$41.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Bumped Off on Bourbon Street murder mystery party

$46.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

As the Beads Drop: Mardi Gras Murder Mystery

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Cinco de Mayo Fiesta murder mystery game

$47.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Cinco de Mayo Mayhem murder mystery game

$46.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

Family St. Patrick's Day Mystery Party

$43.95

Compare Compare Items
Quick View

The Deadly Derby Murder Mystery Party

$47.95

Compare Compare Items